How EU’s deforestation laws might affect smallholder farmers in Africa

Advancing tha cause of environmental conservation, the European Parliament has given the green light to a law that is set to ban imports into the European Union originating from land deforested since December 31, 2020. This decisive measure places the responsibility on companies selling goods to the EU to provide a due diligence statement and “verifiable” evidence proving their products were not grown on deforested land post-2020, under the risk of substantial fines. 

The scope of these regulations is extensive, targeting a range of everyday items prevalent in European markets, including soy, beef, palm oil, wood, cocoa, coffee, rubber, charcoal, as well as derived products such as leather, chocolate, and furniture. The EU, being the second-largest market for these commodities after China, is poised to make a significant impact on global supply chains. 

While the EU’s deforestation laws are hailed as a crucial step towards global sustainability, it is essential to acknowledge potential negative ramifications, particularly for smallholder farmers in Africa. This legislation, aimed at eliminating deforestation from the EU’s supply chains, could inadvertently place a disproportionate burden on vulnerable agricultural communities. 

Smallholder farmers, often the backbone of agriculture in many African nations, may face significant challenges in meeting the stringent requirements set by the EU. The law mandates that companies provide “verifiable” evidence proving their goods were not grown on deforested land after December 31, 2020. For these farmers, who may lack the technological and financial resources to implement geolocation data tracking, compliance becomes a big obstacle. 

The practicality of adhering to such stringent regulations is a concern, especially in regions where infrastructure and technology adoption may lag behind. Smallholders in the palm oil industry, for example, have already voiced their apprehensions about their ability to meet these requirements. The potential consequence is exclusion from a vital market, as they may struggle to provide the necessary proof of their sustainable practices. 

Read also: Simply put, producers and consumers need to embrace sustainability

 The law’s impact extends beyond just palm oil, affecting various commodities crucial to the livelihoods of smallholder farmers, including soy, beef, wood, cocoa, coffee, rubber, and charcoal. As these farmers navigate the complexities of compliance, they risk being left out of lucrative trade opportunities with the EU, leading to economic hardships and threatening food security in their communities. 

It is crucial for the EU to consider the unique challenges faced by smallholder farmers in Africa and explore ways to support them in meeting the sustainability standards set by the legislation. Collaboration with local governments, NGOs, and international bodies could facilitate capacity-building initiatives, providing the necessary tools and knowledge to empower smallholders to participate in sustainable practices. 

In the pursuit of global sustainability, it is essential to strike a balance that ensures positive environmental impact without disproportionately burdening those least equipped to meet stringent requirements. The EU’s deforestation law offers an opportunity for collaboration and support, fostering a more inclusive and sustainable approach that benefits both the environment and the livelihoods of smallholder farmers in Africa.